Who had the better career

[haywallz43]

Settle an argument between my two friends. They both were QBs of the same high school team, and I actually now wanna know which one is better. I’m gonna give a brief overview of both of them. Give me your honest answer. Im pretty biased towards 2012 because I played with him. 12’ had slightly better receivers, 14’ slightly better running backs. So we need some help, which one was better? I’m only providing their senior season stats for various reasons. Their highlight tapes are VERY similar. Both were captains of their teams their senior year.

Overview:
2012: 2.5 year starter. His sophomore year he was OK at best on a bad 3-7 team, his junior year he was just bad for some reason, on a 6-4 team (3 TDs, 7INTs, 600 yards, 46% completion)
-played in run heavy pistol offense
-RBs had 212 carries

2014: 1 year starter. Was JV/Backup QB his soph/jun year
-played in I formation run heavy offense
-RBs had 345 carries

Strengths of QBs:
2012: Arm strength, Athleticism (duel threat)
2014: Accuracy, Football IQ (pocket passer)

Passing stats:
2012: 79/151-52%-1167yards-8TDs/14INT (116 QBR/59 Passer rating) (0/2 2 pt conversions)

Record: (5-5)

2014: 88/141-62%-1059yards-6TDs/5INT (132 QBR/84 Passer rating)
(1/1 2 pt, clutch two point conversion w 1:00 left in game)

Record: (6-4) playoff birth

Rushing stats:
2012: 114/290yards/2TDs/2 lost Fumbles/
(1 of the rushing TDs was a 1 yard QB sneak)

2014: 23/-27/0td/0 Fumbles
(Ran wildcat in certain QB run situations)

[mlittle]

Lane Ruby

[BigChuck]

Lane Ruby

Joe Burrow

[greygoose]

Just going off of stats, and no idea of who their competition was I don't think they should be arguing. Judging by the stats it's like arguing over which penny is better, 2012 penny or 2014 penny both worth the same but neither worth bending over and picking up.

[Bird Dog]

Just going off of stats, and no idea of who their competition was I don't think they should be arguing. Judging by the stats it's like arguing over which penny is better, 2012 penny or 2014 penny both worth the same but neither worth bending over and picking up.

Couldn't agree more

[Ironman92]

I’ll go 2014 by a small amount

[GoIrish]

I’ll say neither because they’re arguing about who was the greater “has been.”